Identifying and Preventing Typical Welding Defects

Identifying and Preventing Typical Welding Defects

Request consulting now

Welding defects affect the load-bearing capacity, operational safety and service life of welded components. They arise from an interplay of material, welding process and process parameters, and range from pores and porosity through hydrogen and solidification cracks to lack of fusion, slag inclusions, undercuts and weld spatter.

Whether a weld defect is critical depends on the application of the component and the design requirements. Permissibility limits are defined in standards such as EN ISO 5817. Unassessed or belatedly detected defects create weak points in the weld, increase the effort for rework and can impair the function of entire welded structures.

The following content shows how to recognise a good weld, which typical defect patterns characterise a poor weld and what measures can be taken to prevent welding defects in planning, material selection and process control.

Common Welding Defects and Their Causes

The most common welding defects occur in fabrication and repair welding as recurring defect patterns. They range from gas-related volumetric defects through separating defects to fusion and undercut defects at the weld. The following overview classifies the typical weld defects and describes what each is and what causes underlie them.

Porosity

Pores are gaseous inclusions in the weld metal and belong to the volumetric defects. In metallurgical porosity, gases such as hydrogen, nitrogen or oxygen dissolve in the liquid weld pool and cannot escape upon rapid solidification. Mechanical porosity is caused by trapped gases in gaps or cavities. Common causes of porosity in the weld are inadequate shielding gas coverage, moisture, contamination such as oil or grease, rust, and coatings or surface treatments on the material surface.










                                                    Porosity

Cracking

Cracks are separating defects in the weld metal or in the heat-affected zone and are considered a particularly critical defect type because they directly reduce the load-bearing capacity of the welded joint. Hydrogen cracks, technically also called cold cracks, arise when atomic hydrogen penetrates the weld metal and heat-affected zone during cooling, especially in areas of high internal stress. Solidification cracks, colloquially often called hot cracks, are promoted by trace elements such as sulphur and phosphorus that accumulate at the weld centreline and form low-melting films at grain boundaries. End crater cracks arise when welding power is reduced too rapidly and the weld pool shrinks strongly during solidification. Cracks due to stress relief annealing and stress corrosion cracking also occur when stress, microstructure and surrounding medium interact unfavourably.










                                                    Cracking

Lack of Fusion

Lack of fusion describes incomplete fusion between the weld metal and the base material, or between individual passes in a multi-pass weld, and reduces the load-bearing cross-section of the joint. Causes include insufficient welding power, too high a welding speed, welding in the downhill position, off-centre arc guidance and too long an arc.










                                                    Lack of Fusion

Slag Inclusions

Slag inclusions are residues of non-metallic slag that remain trapped in the weld metal or between passes in a multi-pass weld and act as material inhomogeneities. They arise from insufficient welding power, too long an arc, inadequate joint preparation, incompletely removed slag from the previous pass, leading slag in the weld pool and unsuitable torch guidance, particularly when using slag-forming flux-cored wires.










                                                    Slag Inclusions

Undercuts

Undercuts are groove-shaped notches at the transition between weld and base material. They act as stress concentrations and reduce the fatigue strength of the welded joint. Causes include too long an arc or too high a voltage, too high a welding speed, too high welding power, excessive weaving and incorrect torch angle.










                                                    Undercuts

Weld Spatter

Weld spatter consists of metal droplets deposited beside the weld during the welding process. They rarely reduce load-bearing capacity, but cause additional post-processing effort and can impair surface quality. Causes include incorrectly set welding parameters, unsuitable polarity, insufficient quality of the filler material and inadequate shielding gas supply.










                                                    Weld Spatter

How Can Welding Defects Be Identified?

Reliable identification of welding defects starts with the defect pattern. The location, shape and progression of the anomaly give immediate information about the defect type and the underlying mechanism. This diagnostic reading is the prerequisite for deriving the correct countermeasure.

Pores and Porosity

Metallurgical pores are mostly round, or elongated when the gas fraction is higher. They lie at the boundary between liquid and solid material and at slag particles in the weld pool. Mechanical pores are often visibly connected to the original cavities or gaps in the joint area. The appearance allows both pore types to be clearly distinguished.

Cracks

Cracks are classified by location and orientation. Hydrogen cracks appear in the weld metal and in the heat-affected zone, often at grain boundaries in the martensite. Solidification cracks appear as longitudinal cracks at the weld centreline. End crater cracks are located in the run-off area of the weld. The position of the crack in the component gives a direct indication of the mechanism of formation.

Lack of Fusion

Lack of fusion defects typically lie at the flanks of the weld or between passes in a multi-pass welded joint. Location and distribution in the weld cross-section give indications of arc guidance and joint preparation.

Slag Inclusions

Slag inclusions are often located between passes of a multi-pass weld and follow the course of the previous pass. The position allows conclusions about torch guidance and interpass cleaning.

Undercuts

Undercuts appear as groove-shaped depressions at the transition between weld and base material. They are visible at the surface and point to the parameter control during welding.

Weld Spatter

Weld spatter is visible as fine to coarse metal droplets beside the weld. Their frequency and distribution allow conclusions about parameters, polarity and shielding gas conditions.

How Can Welding Defects Be Prevented?

Welding defects can rarely be traced back to a single cause. In practice, multiple factors in material, filler material and process control interact. Systematic analysis of these factors is the foundation for sustainably preventing welding defects. The selection of a suitable filler material, safe process control, trained application and controlled conditions at the component are decisive. Depending on the type of defect, additional specific measures apply that address planning, material preparation and welding execution.

capilla accompanies companies from the selection of the suitable filler material, through root cause analysis of recurring defect patterns, to the coordination of stable welding processes for each application.

Preventing Porosity

Pores are reduced by clean and dry material surfaces, removal of rust, grease and unsuitable coatings, and adapted joint preparation. In MIG/MAG welding, sufficient shielding gas flow is decisive, as is a tight gas line, the correct nozzle-to-work distance and the correct orientation of the wire electrode. In manual metal arc welding, a short arc, a steep torch angle, undamaged and concentric electrode coating and a symmetrical earth connection help to reliably shield the arc zone against the atmosphere.

Preventing Cracking

Hydrogen cracks can be prevented by filler materials with a low hydrogen content, re-drying the filler materials before use, preheating the component, reducing stresses and hydrogen relief annealing. Hardening in the weld metal and heat-affected zone must be limited. Solidification cracks are reduced by wider and flatter beads, a reduced depth-to-width ratio, lower dilution with the base material and an adapted welding speed. Cracks during stress relief annealing can be reduced by grinding bead transitions and a coordinated bead sequence in the heat-affected zone. Stress corrosion cracking is prevented by clean weld transitions, suitable component design and a construction that deliberately reduces stress peaks. End crater cracks are prevented by a controlled completion of the weld, use of the crater fill function and sufficient fill time.

Preventing Lack of Fusion

Lack of fusion defects are prevented by sufficient welding power, adapted welding speed, centred arc guidance and a short arc. Careful joint preparation and torch guidance appropriate to the welding position ensure complete fusion between weld metal and base material.

Preventing Slag Inclusions

Slag inclusions are reduced by sufficient welding power, a short arc and careful joint preparation. Between passes in a multi-pass weld, the slag must be completely removed. Adapted torch guidance prevents slag from running ahead in the weld pool, particularly when using slag-forming flux-cored wires.

Preventing Undercuts

Undercuts are prevented by adapted welding power, controlled welding speed, suitable voltage and a short arc. Excessive weaving must be limited and the torch angle must suit the weld path.

Preventing Weld Spatter

Weld spatter is effectively limited by correctly set welding parameters, suitable polarity, filler material of adequate quality and a reliable shielding gas supply.

capiLab – Our In-House Testing Laboratory

All relevant testing methods are combined in the capiLab directly in-house. This saves time, reduces coordination effort and enables fast, well-founded results.

Material testing, hardness analyses and damage assessments interlock and provide a reliable basis for decisions.

Learn more about capiLab
capilla-ansprechpartner-andreas-frische.webp
Andreas Frische
Technical Management

Preventing Welding Defects and Stabilising Processes

Do you have recurring welding defects or are you uncertain about root cause analysis?

Our experts support you in evaluating your welding processes and in selecting suitable filler materials. Together we identify causes and develop solutions that work reliably in your application.

+49 5202 97790-54
Available from 07:45 - 16:30
a.frische@capilla-gmbh.de
Available from 07:45 - 16:30

Frequently Asked Questions on Welding Defects

Welding defects are irregularities in a weld that deviate from the intended specification and can impair the mechanical properties, load-bearing capacity or operational safety of the welded joint. They generally arise from an interplay of material, welding process and process parameters. Which deviations count as defects and which as permissible irregularities is determined by the requirements for the component and the applicable standards. capilla supports companies in classifying typical defect patterns and selecting suitable filler materials for prevention.

The most common welding defects include porosity, cracking in various forms such as hydrogen, solidification and end crater cracks, lack of fusion, slag inclusions, undercuts and weld spatter. Technically they are classified into volumetric defects, separating defects and fusion and undercut defects at the weld. capilla advises on preventing these defect patterns through appropriately matched filler materials and correct process control.

In metal active gas welding, typical welding defects include primarily pores – both metallurgically caused by insufficient shielding gas coverage and mechanically by moisture, contamination or coatings in the joint area. Additionally, lack of fusion from insufficient welding power, slag inclusions when using slag-forming flux-cored wires and weld spatter from unsuitable parameters and polarity occur. capilla offers filler materials for MIG/MAG welding and supports with advice on parameter selection to reduce these defect patterns.

Lack of fusion describes incomplete fusion between the weld metal and the base material or between individual passes in a multi-pass weld. It reduces the load-bearing cross-section of the joint and is caused primarily by insufficient welding power, too high a welding speed, welding in the downhill position, off-centre arc guidance or too long an arc. capilla supports with expert advice on selecting the appropriate filler material and process control to ensure reliable fusion.

Shrinkage cavities are voids that form during solidification of a metal due to volume contraction. They are primarily a defect pattern from foundry technology. In welding, the phenomenon occurs in a limited form as end crater cavities, when welding power is reduced too rapidly at the weld end and the weld pool shrinks strongly during solidification. Classic welding defects such as pores, cracks, lack of fusion or slag inclusions are to be distinguished from these. capilla supports in selecting suitable filler materials and process-side design of the weld run-off to prevent end crater defects.

Cracks during welding arise when stresses, unfavourable microstructure states or introduced elements exceed the ductility of the weld metal or heat-affected zone. Hydrogen cracks arise from atomic hydrogen that penetrates the weld metal and heat-affected zone during cooling and triggers cracks in areas of high internal stress. Solidification cracks are promoted by sulphur and phosphorus that accumulate in the weld centreline during solidification and form low-melting films at grain boundaries. End crater cracks arise at the weld run-off when welding power is reduced too rapidly. capilla offers low-hydrogen filler materials and advises on material and process selection to specifically reduce susceptibility to cracking.

Hot cracks, technically solidification cracks, occur with increased risk in dissimilar metal joints – that is, welded joints between different base materials. The cause is the dilution of the weld metal with two different materials, which can lead to unfavourable concentrations of low-melting trace elements at grain boundaries, to microstructure transformations and to stresses from different thermal expansion coefficients. Critical factors are the selection of a suitable filler material with controlled dilution behaviour and adapted process control that limits dilution with the base materials. capilla advises on material and filler material selection for dissimilar metal joints and supports in preventing hot cracks in demanding welding applications.

Welding defects create weak points in the weld and increase the effort for rework. They cause additional costs, delays in fabrication and can impair the operational safety of a component. How critically a defect manifests itself depends on the application of the component and the design requirements. capilla supports companies in systematically analysing recurring defect patterns and preventing them through suitable filler materials and process coordination.

Assessment is based on the application of the component and the requirements for the design. Which irregularities are permissible is already defined during design. The relevant permissibility limits are defined in standards such as EN ISO 5817, which specifies assessment groups for welds in metallic materials. capilla advises on classifying weld defects in the respective application and selecting suitable filler materials for the required assessment group.

The filler material directly influences mechanical properties, solidification behaviour and susceptibility to typical welding defects. Low-hydrogen filler materials reduce the risk of hydrogen cracks; correct re-drying before use maintains the low hydrogen content. A material combination of base material and filler material suited to the application reduces the risk of solidification cracks and dilution problems. capilla develops filler materials for demanding applications and supports in selecting the appropriate filler material for the respective welding process.